Transgender sensitivity video tells police to let men into women’s washrooms
A new transgender sensitivity video from the
Department of Justice (DOJ) instructs police officers on how to deal with
complaints about men using women’s restrooms and instructs them to ask people
if they’d rather be called “sir” or “ma’am.”
“When someone’s name or gender on a license is
different from what you expect, how do you react?” Cpl. Evan Baxter asks in the
video. “Is this person committing identity theft? Are they a fugitive? Possibly
they’re just transgender.”
The DOJ’s Community Relations Service made the
training video titled “Law Enforcement and the Transgender Community” in
consultation with LGBT advocacy groups. The video depicts three scenarios in
which law enforcement might come in contact with the “transgender community.”
In the first scenario, a police officer asks a
man dressed as a woman for his license and registration after pulling him over
for a taillight issue. The police officer asks the driver, “Do you prefer if I
call you ma’am or sir?”
“I don’t have to be in the room with you to
know what probably just happened,” Sgt. Brett Parson says when the scenario has
ended. “Somebody just snickered, laughed, or made a joke. Trust me, I know. I’m
a cop, too. As police officers, we use humor to deal with things that make us
uncomfortable or afraid. We’re human — and we know we mean no harm. It’s our
way of coping. But we have to admit it: to outsiders, it’s perceived as
unprofessional and disrespectful. Remember, you never get a second chance to
make a first impression. If someone feels disrespected, they’re less likely to
trust us or cooperate.”
In the second scenario, a police officer
privately reprimands her co-worker for sneering at an assault victim and
calling him “sir” instead of “ma’am.” The offending officer apologizes and
corrects the situation by asking the victim how he’d like to be addressed.
In the third scenario, a young woman holding a
baby calls the police to report that she saw a man going into the women’s
restroom. The individual, who is wearing makeup and appears to be quite
feminine, explains to the officer, “I’m a woman.”
“Probably a misunderstanding,” the officer
apologizes.
‘Not just a man with a wig’
“There’s a perception among many transgender
people that police won’t take crime against them seriously — that they’ll
actually blame the victim for looking or dressing or being the way they are,”
Parson said. “And in recent surveys, some transgender people have reported that
they have been assaulted by police officers. Many transgender women, if they’re
on the street at night, actually fear getting stopped for something we call
‘walking while trans.’ The assumption by officers is that they’re soliciting
[sex], but they might just be hanging out or waiting for a ride. Just being
transgender isn’t a reason to suspect a crime. … There’s an enormous need to
repair this trust.”
“So many women and people in the transgender
community just see law enforcement as a non-ally,” Debbie McMillan of the
Women’s Collective explains. “I think the police need to have an understanding
of what it means to be transgender. … I am not just a man with a wig.”
Parson instructed viewers on the proper
distinctions between “assigned sex,” “sexual orientation,” and “gender
identity.”
“We need to take a closer look at three basic
terms and the distinct differences between how we define them,” Parson said.
“Assigned sex,” which is “also known as birth
sex … refers to the biological or physiological designation as male or female
at birth, usually based on anatomy,” he said. “Every person has an internal,
psychological gender identity — a sense of who they feel they are in terms of
gender, even if it’s not consistent with their assigned sex.”
This is “best viewed as a broad spectrum” with
“masculine male at one end and feminine female at the other end,” Parson said.
“Law Enforcement and the Transgender
Community” does not make reference to or acknowledge “gender non-binary,”
“genderqueer,”
or “two-spirit”
people.
The video also instructs law enforcement to
use the word “transgender” instead of “trans.”
“While it may be acceptable to some, the
safest term to use is the entire word transgender,” Parson said. “When in
doubt, it’s always best to ask an individual what their preference is. Just
simply ask, ‘How would you like to be addressed?’ Using the correct or
preferred pronouns demonstrates respect and lets the individual know that
you’re knowledge about their community, which is both reassuring and shows
you’re a true professional.”