If I am a Christian who experiences same-sex attraction, should I pray to not have homosexual feelings?
It reflects a desire to become more faithful to Christ and more conformed to his image. This certainly includes our sexual orientation. We should also pray, "Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil" (v. 13).
Asking God to draw us away from things that tempt us should be the content of our prayer. We should ask God to replace gay homosexual temptation with holiness. Heterosexuals are also tempted sexually. "Lead us not into temptation" is a prayer for both the heterosexual Christian and the Christian battling same-sex attraction, or any other form of sexual desire. We don't celebrate murder, adultery, lying nor should we celebrate homosexuality.