Idaho ministers face fines, jail time for refusing to perform same-sex ‘marriages’

-
Ministers in the state of Idaho are facing fines and potential jail time for refusing to perform same-sex “marriages,” even though homosexuality violates their religion.
In 2013, the Idaho city of Coeur D'Alene passed a law that forces all businesses to consider homosexuals the same as racial minorities when it comes to housing, employment, and "public accommodation," regardless of religious beliefs. Religious institutions are exempt from the ordinance – but according to the city, the ministers who run The Hitching Post, a wedding chapel, do not qualify for an exemption because their business operates for profit.
The battle came to a head earlier this year, after Idaho's marriage law was overturned by a federal court. At the time, a deputy attorney for the city said that The Hitching Post would have to follow the ordinance because it charges what the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) calls "a small fee" to conduct the ceremony and provide marriage materials with a Christian theme.
Last week, after Idaho declined to defend its state marriage law, a man called the proprietors of The Hitching Post about "marrying" another man. Donald and Evelyn Knapp declined to provide him that service, and immediately sued the city to prevent the ordinance's punishments – including fines and imprisonment – from applying to them. Fines could total as much as $1,000 for each day the Knapps do not follow the ordinance, and jail time could total 180 days.
ADF Senior Legal Counsel Jeremy Tedesco told LifeSiteNews that while The Hitching Post's owners are conducting a service that is required by the state -- all weddings require "solemnizing" -- "people don’t forfeit their First Amendment rights just because they are somehow involved with the government."
"For example," said Tedesco, "the Supreme Court has held that attorneys cannot be forced to abandon their political views to become a member of a state bar. Neither can the government force ministers to abandon their religious beliefs when solemnizing weddings."
"In fact, the Idaho solemnization law lists 16 broad categories of persons who may solemnize marriages," explained Tedesco. "Our clients should not be compelled by law to violate their faith when people in Idaho desiring a same-sex marriage ceremony have a plethora of options.”
UCLA professor and conservative legal blogger Eugene Volokh wrote that the local ordinance may violate Idaho's Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA). According to Volokh, "compelling them to speak words in ceremonies that they think are immoral is an unconstitutional speech compulsion."
"I think the Knapps are also entitled to an exemption under the Idaho RFRA," continued Volokh. "The Knapps allege that 'sincerely held religious beliefs prohibit them from performing, officiating, or solemnizing a wedding ceremony between anyone other than one man and one woman'; I know of no reason to think they’re lying about their beliefs. Requiring them to violate their beliefs (or close their business) is a substantial burden on their religious practice."
Volokh also says the Free Speech and Establishment Clauses of the U.S. Constitution could be violated if the city forces the Knapps to follow the ordinance.
The office of Coeur d’Alene Mayor Steve Widmeyer did not return multiple requests for comment from LifeSiteNews about the case.

Popular posts from this blog

Ontario Catholic school board to vote on flying gay ‘pride flag’ at all board-run schools

-
Image
A Catholic school board in Ontario will vote next week on a motion to fly the rainbow-colored homosexual pride flag at all board-run schools during the month of June. Halton Catholic District School Board (HCDSB) Trustee Brenda Agnew gave notice of her motion titled “supporting our diverse school community” during an April 6 board meeting. Quoting Pope Francis along with LGBT talking points about “equity and inclusion,” the motion calls for the Board’s Director of Education Pat Daly to “direct all HCDSB schools including the Catholic Education Centre to fly the Pride flag during the month of June starting with 2021.” The motion is expected to be voted on by the Board at their next meeting on April 20. With nine trustees, the motion requires five votes to pass. A tied vote results in a fail. The HCDSB states on its website that its mission is to provide “excellence in Catholic education by developing Christ-centred individuals enabled to transform society.” The Catholic Church, basing i...
Read more

Christian baker must make ‘wedding’ bakes for gay couples, court rules

-
Image
DENVER, CO ,  – A Colorado board has ruled that a Christian business owner must make wedding cakes for homosexual "marriages" despite his religious objections. Business owner Jack Phillips came under legal fire in 2012, when he refused to bake a cake for Dave Mullins and Charlie Craig , who had traveled to Massachusetts for a marriage license, and wanted to celebrate in their home state. They sued on the basis of a state law that prevents the application of religious beliefs if one owns a business. The Commission's ruling, which was issued verbally on Friday, orders Phillips to report every three months for the next two years on anti-discrimination training for his staff, and any customers who are refused service at his establishment. "I can believe anything I want, but if I'm going to do business here, I'd ought to not discriminate against people," said one of the Civil Rights Commission 's seven members in a public statement. Phil...
Read more

Australia: Gay Hate tribunals are coming

-
Image
Are Hate Tribunals Are Coming In Canada , it is considered discriminatory to say that marriage is between a man and a woman or that every child should know and be raised by his or her biological married parents.  It is not just politically incorrect in Canada to say so; you can be saddled with tens of thousands of dollars in legal fees, fined, and forced to take sensitivity training. Anyone who is offended by something you have said or written can make a complaint to the Human Rights Commissions and Tribunals. In Canada, these organizations police speech, penalizing citizens for any expression deemed in opposition to particular sexual behaviors or protected groups identified under “sexual orientation.” It takes only one complaint against a person to be brought before the tribunal, costing the defendant tens of thousands of dollars in legal fees. The commissions have the power to enter private residences and remove all items pertinent to their investigations, checkin...
Read more