LGB vs. T: A crackup is looming in the LGBT community
Prediction: by 2020,
the LGBT acronym will have disappeared. The Ls, the Gs, the Bs, and the Ts will
still be with us. But their alliance against the “straight” world will have
broken up.
You can already hear the distant boom-boom of
breaking ice. The latest absurd episode of LGB versus T took place in the
American state of Maine earlier this week at Kennebunk
High School. As a feature of its diversity
week the school was to be the first in the state to fly the gay pride rainbow
flag. But it was hauled down after a trans student complained that it might
embarrass other trans students.
Something
similar happened last year at the University of
British Columbia. A trans woman incinerated a gay pride flag hoisted to
celebrate LGBT OutWeek festivities. She later explained that she felt
diminished when the university applauded the LGBT community. "Transsexual
people do struggle with being marginalized within the LGBT community,"
said the chair of Vancouver's Trans Alliance Society.
This is not a new idea, either. A couple of
years ago, a gay activist wrote a
much-criticised column in USA Today which
argued that LGBs and Ts should go their separate ways:
Make no mistake, the gay community needs to file
for divorce with the trans community. They are no longer working
toward the same goals ... Unlike members of the trans community, who
are working against their biology and trying to change who they are
physically, gay or lesbian people are trying to be nobody but themselves.
They are not seeking surgery or hormone treatments. They love the same
gender; they don’t want to be a different gender.
Homosexuality represents a mistake about the
purpose of sexuality; it is not a mistake about biology. Gays and lesbians
affirm and even exaggerate their masculinity and femininity. The claim of
transgenders is far more radical. They deny that the sex with which they were
born with has any inherent meaning; it is just a matter of choice. So it’s just
a matter of time before this marriage of convenience dissolves. The various
groups will recognise that they have little in common other than feeling
aggrieved by conventional sexual mores.
The hostility felt by some gays and lesbians
towards the trans movement is matched or even exceeded by the fury of some
feminists. Germaine
Greer, the famously profane Australian feminist
icon of the 70s and 80s, is fed up. A couple of years ago she was vilified for
speaking her mind in a statement to a popular BBC show:
“Just because you lop off your penis and then wear a
dress doesn't make you a ******* woman. I’ve asked my doctor to give me long
ears and liver spots and I’m going to wear a brown coat but that won’t turn me
into a ******* cocker spaniel.
The view of radical feminists is that trans
women are living in a world of Barbie doll femininity; they have not suffered
under the oppression of the patriarchy and do not deserve to masquerade as
women. They were outraged when Caitlyn (Bruce) Jenner told Buzzfeed “The hardest part about being a woman
is figuring out what to wear” -- not bearing children, raising children, coping
with sexism or making ends meet.
Take, for instance, the eminent BBC presenter
Jenni Murray. She was under fire earlier this month over an article she wrote
in the Sunday Times Magazine about
trans women. She denied being “transphobic”, but said that sex changes cannot
turn men into “real women”. (The BBC chastised her for her incendiary remarks –
so much for free speech!)
The issue has also split feminist
theoreticians. Some scholars feel that trans women are just men colonising
femininity. In their eyes, it’s a new strategy of dominance dreamed up by the
same old patriarchy that invented glass ceilings. Janice
Raymond, the author of a number of well-known
feminist books, argues that the transgender movement threatens to unravel
feminism:
“If we have to change our bodies in order to challenge
gender norms, we are not transcending gender, ie, we are not free from gender.
We are exchanging one gendered identity for the other. I think the task of
radical feminism is to dismantle gender wherever it rears its hydra-headed
appearance.”
If the New York
Times is an accurate barometer of cultural trends, then feminism is
in danger of being eclipsed by transgender issues, even though 49.6 percent of
the world population are women, and only 0.3 percent (if that) are transgender.
Wednesday March 8 was International Women’s Day (even Donald Trump tweeted
about it), but you wouldn’t know it from looking at the editorial pages of
the Times. What did catch the eye was a
powerful op-ed column published the day before by Gavin
Grimm, the trans boy at the centre of a legal fight
in Virginia.
Conservatives are fond of quoting the
prophetic words of the poet W.B. Yeats: “Things fall apart; the centre cannot
hold; Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world.” But the first things to fall
apart will be the ragtag alliance of opponents of traditional sexual mores and
traditional marriage.
Reprinted with permission from MercatorNet.